Watertight-intent dural reconstruction may reduce incisional cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage after decompressive craniectomy but may prolong surgery. We aimed to evaluate whether watertight-intent reconstruction, compared with non-watertight management, was associated with direct postoperative incisional CSF leakage and operative time.
Five databases were searched through August 1, 2026. Comparative studies with explicit watertight or sealing-intent reconstruction and non-watertight comparators were included. The primary outcome was direct incisional CSF leakage; secondary outcomes included operative time, wound or surgical-site infection, hydrocephalus, mortality, and functional outcomes. Binary outcomes were expressed as risk ratios (RRs), and continuous outcomes as mean differences. Random-effects meta-analysis used restricted maximum likelihood estimation with Wald 95% confidence intervals (CIs); randomized and observational studies were examined as subgroups, with Hartung–Knapp sensitivity analyses. Certainty of evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation framework.
Twelve studies were included; nine (1,314 participants) reported direct incisional CSF leakage. Watertight-intent reconstruction was associated with fewer reported leaks (RR, 0.54; Wald 95% CI, 0.34–0.86; I² = 23.3%), although the prediction interval included the null value (0.24–1.20). The randomized subgroup was imprecise (RR, 0.75; 95% CI, 0.32–1.73), whereas the observational subgroup favored reconstruction (RR, 0.43; 95% CI, 0.20–0.90); its Hartung–Knapp interval (0.14–1.32) crossed 1. Infection and hydrocephalus estimates were imprecise; mortality and function were not pooled. Reconstruction was associated with longer operative time (mean difference, 39.85 minutes; 95% CI, 25.14–54.56; I² = 97.4%). Certainty was very low for all key outcomes.
Watertight-intent reconstruction is associated with fewer reported incisional CSF leaks and longer operations, although certainty is very low. Limited study and event numbers, imprecise design subgroups, and multicomponent techniques preclude causal or universal treatment conclusions. Effects on infection, hydrocephalus, mortality, and function remain uncertain.
Full article