Introduction
C282Y and H63D mutations in the HFE gene were identified in patients with hemochromatosis (HC) in 1996.1 One year later, the C282Y mutation responsible for autosomal recessive HC was shown to be prevalent in Caucasians but rare in non-Caucasians.2 Subsequent clinical investigations confirmed that there were a large number of patients with the C282Y mutation and a small number of non-C282Y mutations in the HFE gene of Caucasian patients.3 However, both genotypes were very rare in Japanese patients.4 Nevertheless, a small number of patients were affected not only by autosomal recessive HC associated with mutations in TFR2,5HJV,6 and HAMP,7 but also by autosomal dominant ferroportin (FP) disease (FP-D) with mutant genes in SLC40A1,8,9 regardless of ethnicity.
Aceruloplasminemia (ACP) was initially reported in a Japanese patient with the iron-induced middle-aged onset of diabetes mellitus (DM), dementia, and retinopathy.10 It is now regarded as a worldwide core disease of neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation (NBIA).11 Biochemical tests are characterized by the lack of circulating ceruloplasmin (CP), namely ferroxidase, and resultant circulating transferrin (TF) with a low iron saturation (TSAT) under systemic iron overloading. DM in ACP complicated with NBIA is multifactorial because, in addition to the pancreas, most endocrine organs including the pituitary gland, are affected by iron overloading.12
Evidence has accumulated for a molecule-based mechanism of iron absorption in the gut and internal iron recycling between the spleen and bone marrow. The main molecules involved in iron homeostasis are the iron regulatory hormone hepcidin25 (Hep25)13,14 and the iron exporter FP.15 The clinical introduction of Hep25 has allowed for the classification of primary iron overload syndromes (PIOSs) based on the Hep25/FP system.16 Serum levels of Hep25 are low in ACP and HC, but are high in FP-D. ACP is always associated with low circulating Hep25 under low TSAT, while impaired hepatic synthesis of Hep25 has been identified as a pathogenic factor for hepatic HC.13 The mutant FP molecules coded by the SLC40A1 gene have been shown to resist circulating Hep25 in the gut and macrophages,17 thereby disturbing iron homeostasis. Based on these findings, we proposed a classification of PIOSs in 2012 consisting of the following three categories: prehepatic ACP, hepatic HC, and posthepatic FP-D.18
The subsequent accumulation of evidence since the initial proposal in 2012 indicated that the classification of PIOSs needs to be renewed based on the Hep25/FP system: new evidence of the involvement of the erythroferrone (ERFE)/Hep25/FP system in iron-loading anemia (ILA),19–21 the controversial state of traditional FP-D,22,23 and the identification of the two genotypes of C282Y and non-C282Y HFE-HC in Japanese patients.24,25 In addition, ACP has been introduced into the international monographs of PIOSs.26,27 Therefore, the classification of PIOSs was revised as the classification of HC by the BIOIRON Society23 and the guidelines of HC by the EASL.28
Methods
This study included Japanese patients enrolled in the first classification of PIOSs proposed in 2012.18 Five patients had TFR2-HC, three had HJV-HC, and one had HAMP-HC. No patient with HFE-HC was enrolled in the first study. The first classification also included two subtypes of PIOSs other than HC. Four had ACP and three had FP-D. They were diagnosed by the standard criteria of ACP,10 HC,3 and FP-D.3 Direct sequencing of HFE, TFR2, HJV, HAMP, and SLC40A1 was performed for patients with HC and FP-D. CP was analyzed in patients with ACP. Serum levels of Hep25 were assessed by LC-MS/MS.29
In the decade after the publication of the first study in 2012, 17 Japanese patients with PIOSs were retrospectively identified and newly enrolled in the revised classification. ILA has been added as a disease entity of PIOSs based on confirmation of the ERFE-induced suppression of Hep25 in a wide range of genetic anemias associated with hemolysis and recituclocytosis.19–21 The inclusion criteria of ILA are anemias associated with ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis, low levels of circulating Hep25, and iron-induced multiorgan damage.19,20 The same criteria as those used in the first study, such as hyperferritinemia, iron-induced organ damage, and the detection of disease-causing mutations, have been employed to diagnose ACP, HC, and SLC40A1-PIOSs.18 Serum Hep25 levels were used for differential diagnosis of the prehepatic and hepatic PIOSs associated with pathologically low Hep25 and posthepatic SLC40A1-PIOSs with adequate Hep25. As the state of traditional FP-D is controversial.22,23 we examined the phenotypes of SLC40A1-PIOSs using the additional criterion of long-term follow-up.22 The clinical study included an assessment of serum Hep25 levels and a genetic analysis of PIOSs, which were performed after obtaining informed consent from each patient. Instead of informed consent, OPTOUT was permitted for patients. There were two exceptional cases, a patient with ILA diagnosed after autopsy and an aged patient in a PIEZO1-induced dihydrated hereditary stomatocytosis (DHS) family. They missed the opportunity for a Hep25 assessment and gene analysis. The publication of anonymized results in an international journal was approved by the Ethics Committees of each institute.
Results
The number of patients increased from 16 in the original study to 34 in the revised version, 11 with prehepatic PIOSs (5 ACP and 6 ILA), 15 with hepatic PIOSs (3 HFE, 5 TFR2, 6 HJV, and 1 HAMP), and eight with posthepatic PIOSs (5 SLC40A1-HC and 3 FP-D). Anonymized information of the patients with the prehepatic class of ACP and ILA is summarized in Tables 1 and 2,16,18,30–34 and that of HC and SLC40A1-PIOSs is shown in Table 3.16–20,22,24,25,35–40 The clinical features of new patients in each disease category are described briefly, and the characteristics of each category are summarized in Table 4.18–21,23
Table 1Patients with prehepatic ACP
Class | Disease | Genetic Study | Age/Sex | Serum ferritin, ng/mL | Serum Hep25, ng/mL | TSAT, %, (Hb, g/dL), CP, mg/mL | Organ damage | Ref |
---|
Prehepatic | ACP-1 | 2679G>A, homozygous in CP | 35/M | 3,530 | BDL | 16.3 (9.5) BDL | Hepatocyte-dominant iron, DM, osteomyelitis | 30 |
| ACP-2 | 1285-1286ins5, homozygous in CP | 44/M | 961 | 2.7 | 22.0 (12.3) BDL | Hepatocyte-dominant iron, DM, hypopituitarism | 18 |
| ACP-3 | 2630G>A, homozygous in CP | 55/F | 1,035 | 13.1 | 14.6 (9.4) BDL | Mixed-cell iron, DM | 16,18 |
| ACP-4 | 606-607insA, homozygous in CP | 59/F | 885 | 10.3 | 11.2 (10.2) BDL | Hepatocyte-dominant iron, DM, dementia | 16,18 |
| ACP-5 | 1285-1286ins5, homozygous in CP | 62/M | 1,140 | 18.2 | 12.0 (8.9) BDL | Mixed-cell iron, DM, cardiac failure, dementia | 16,18 |
Table 2Patients with prehepatic ILA
Class | Disease | Genetic study | Age/Sex | Serum ferritin, ng/mL | Serum Hep25, ng/mL | TSAT, %, (Hb, g/mL), reticulo-C, ‰ | Organ damage | Ref |
---|
Prehepatic | ILA-1 | 6008C>A, heterozygous in PIEZO1 | 23/F | 815 | 4.2 | 85.2 (9.9) 84 | Liver iron accumulation in imaging, anemia, neither DM nor endocrine disorders | 32 |
| (DHS) | | | | | | | |
| ILA-2 | 3503C>T, heterozygous in CDAN1 | 38/M | 4,058 | nd | 95.3 (7.5) 27 | HC-liver, anemia, DM, hypogonadism | 33 |
| (CDA-type 1) | | 48/M | 186 | 0.8 | nd (8.5) nd | | |
| | | Post-Ph | | | | | |
| ILA-3 | 7488-7489insACTGGA, heterozygous in PIEZO1 | 41/M | 4,350 | 3.2 | 120 (6.6) 49 | HC-liver, anemia, MD, gallstones | 31 |
| (DHS) | | | | | | | |
| ILA-4 | 7488-7489insACTGGA, heterozygous in PIEZO1 | 50/F | 4,315 | nd | nd (7.9) 39 | HC-liver, anemia, MD, hypothyroidism, hypogonadism | 31 |
| (DHS) | | | | | | | |
| ILA-5 | nd | 61/F | 1,960 | nd | 96.0 (10.7) nd | HC-liver, anemia, DM, cardiac failure | 34 |
| ILA-6 | nd | 82/M | 5,141 | nd | nd (10.2) 100 | HC-liver, DM, hypothyroidism | 31 |
| (DHS) | (A member of the DHS family) | | | | | | |
Table 3Patients with hepatic HC and posthepatic SLC40A1-PIOS
Class | Disease | Genetic study | Age/Sex | Serum ferritin, ng/mL | Serum Hep25, ng/mL | TSAT, 40–70% | Organ damage | Ref |
---|
Hepatic | HFE-HC-1 | 691-693del (Y231del), homozygous in HFE | 42/F | 423 | nd | 85.7 | Iron deposits in the liver and pancreas on abdominal imaging, liver dysfunction, DM, oligomenorrhea | 25 |
| | | Post-Ph | 192 | 19.6 | 71 | | |
| HFE-HC-2 | 691-693del (Y231del), homozygous in HFE | 43/M | 1,698 | nd | 120 | Liver dysfunction, DM | 25 |
| | | Post- Ph | 150 | 4 | 88.7 | | |
| HFE-HC-3 | 845G>A (C282Y), homozygous in HFE | 65/F | 5,660 | nd | 89.8 | HC-liver, DM, pigmentation | 24 |
| TFR2-HC-1 | 1199T>G/2008-2009delAC in TFR2 | 40/M | 10,191 | 12.2 | 94.2 | HC-liver, DM, hypogonadism | 16,18 |
| TFR2-HC-2 | 1861-1862del12, homozygous in TFR2 | 47/M | 4,400 | BDL | 90.6 | HC-liver, pigmentation | 18 |
| TFR2-HC-3 | 1469T>G, homozygous in TFR2 | 49/M | 1,057 | 2.8 | 93.5 | HC-liver, DM | 16,18 |
| TFR2-HC-4 | 1861-1862del12, homozygous in TFR2 | 50/M | 2,485 | BDL | 94.5 | No liver biopsy, liver dysfunction | 18 |
| TFR2-HC-5 | 1861-1862del12, homozygous in TFR2 | 53/F | 1,470 | BDL | 93.2 | HC-liver | 18 |
| HJV-HC-1 | 515-516insC, homozygous in HJV | 13/M | 16,000 | nd | 90 | Liver fibrosis, cardiac disease | 18 |
| | | 29M | 6,624 | BDL | 94.4 | HC-liver, cardiac failure | |
| HJV-HC-2 | 515-516insC, homozygous in HJV | 17/M | 2,500 | nd | 92 | DM | 18 |
| | | 33/M | 2,222 | 2 | 94 | No liver biopsy, DM | |
| HJV-HC-3 | 842T>C, homozygous in HJV | 37/F | 2,274 | BDL | 93 | HC-liver, DM, hypogonadism | 35 |
| HJV-HC-4 | 449A>G/820G>A, compound heterozygous in HJV | 39/M | 6,421 | 7.4 | 98.4 | Iron overload on abdominal imaging, liver | 36 |
| | | | | | | dysfunction | |
| HJV-HC-5 | 745G>C, homozygous in HJV | 48/M | 6,115 | BDL | 94.8 | HC-liver, DM, cardiac failure, pigmentation | 18 |
| HJV-HC-6 | 842T>C, homozygous in HJV | 52/F | 4,340 | BDL | 92 | Liver dysfunction, DM, hypogonadism, cardiac failure | 35 |
| HAMP-HC-1 | 223C>T, homozygous in HAMP | 45/M | 3,000 | nd | 94.4 | HC-liver, DM, hypogonadism, pigmentation | 18 |
| | | 58/M | 16.3 | BDL | 11.6 | | |
| | | Post-Ph | | | | | |
Post-Hepatic | SLC40A1- | 1520A>G, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 42/M | 3,751 | 132.5 | 93 | Liver dysfunction, cataracts, DM | 37 |
| HC-1 | | | | | | | |
| SLC40A1- | 1520A>G, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 46/M | 1,722 | 139.6 | 91.3 | HC-liver, DM | 38 |
| HC-2 | | | | | | | |
| SLC40A1- | 470A>C, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 66/M | 7,980 | 156.7 | 89.3 | FP-liver, DM, pigmentation | 16,18,40 |
| HC-3 | | | | | | | |
| SLC40A1- | No mutation detected in SLC40A1 | 79/F | 6,403 | 185.6 | 88.3 | FP-liver, DM, pigmentation | 40 |
| HC-4 | | | | | | | |
| SLC40A1- | 470A>C, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 79/M | 18,610 | nd | 95.8 | FP-liver, hypopituitarism | 39 |
| HC-5 | | | | | | | |
| FP-D-1 | 1467A>C, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 49/M | 696 | 42.5 | 28.6 | Mild mixed iron, no liver dysfunction, no organ damage | 16,18 |
| FP-D-2 | 238G>A, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 66/F | 1,832 | 79 | 43.4 | Severe mixed iron, no liver dysfunction, no organ damage | unpublished |
| FP-D-3 | 1467A>C, heterozygous in SLC40A1 | 81/M | 2,639 | 155 | 88.3 | No liver dysfunction, no organ damage | 16,18 |
Table 4Summary of the characteristics of primary iron overload syndromes
Class | Disease | Serum ferritin | Serum Hep25 | Responsible gene and detection of disease-causing mutations/patients | Other diagnostic index and main organ damage | Phlebotomy and other options |
---|
reference: 13–277 ng/mL for M; 5–15 ng/mL for F | reference: 1.6–12.7 ng/mL |
---|
Prehepatic | ACP | High | Low | CP, 5/5 | CP deficiency, low TSAT, central DM, CNS disorders | Intolerance, Oral chelation |
| ILA | High | Low | Various genetic anemias: PIEZO1: 3/4, CDAN1:1/1, nd: 0/1 | Ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis, Overproduction of ERFE, Cirrhosis, DM, pigmentation, cardiac failure | No indication; Oral chelation; Transfusion/oral chelation |
Hepatic | HC | High | Low or BDL*2 | HFE, 3/3; TFR2, 5/5; HIV, 6/6; HAMP, 1/1 | HC-liver, DM, pigmentation, cardiac failure | Good tolerance |
| | | | | | |
Post-hepatic | SLC40A1-HC | High | High | SLC40A1 (Gain of function) 4/5 | FP-liver, Mixed-cell iron cirrhosis, DM, pigmentation, cardiac failure | Good tolerance; Oral chelation tolerance |
| SLC40A1- FP-D | High | High | SLC40A1 (Loss of function) 3/3 | mixed-cell iron | None needed |
One of the five patients was newly enrolled in ACP of prehepatic PIOSs (Table 1).30 A 35-year-old male patient had a large discrepancy between serum ferritin and Hep25: 3,530 ng/mL vs. below the detection limit (BDL). TSAT was low at 16.3%. As summarized in Table 4, the clinical features of ACP were deficient levels of serum CP coded by the CP gene and resultant low TSAT values and serum Hep25 levels. Serum ferritin levels were high and a large amount of iron was deposited in hepatocytes; however, the liver showed neither inflammation nor fibrosis. All patients had DM, and central nervous system (CNS) disorders, including cognitive failure, were late complications.
In the last decade, we identified six patients affected by PIOS compatible with ILA (Table 1).31–34 The etiologies of genetic anemias associated with ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis varied. Two patients with DHS in one family30 and one patient with the same disease in another family31 had PIEZO1-induced hemolytic anemia associated with hypohepcidinemia. An 82-year-old male patient with PIOS in the first family30 missed the opportunity for a gene analysis for autosomal dominant disease and an assessment of serum Hep25 levels. A 48-year-old male patient with congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) type 133 was affected by ILA associated with a heterozygous mutation in the CDAN1 gene. A 61-year-old female patient34 died from congestive heart failure associated with the HC triad of cirrhosis, MD, and pigmentation. She had a history of severe anemia since adolescence but did not have a previous history of iron supplementation or transfusion. An autopsy confirmed iron-induced multiorgan damage, but opportunities for an assessment of Hep25 levels and a genetic analysis were missed. All six patients with ILA had severe anemia with hemoglobin (Hb) between 6.6 and 10.7 g/mL, and varied reticulocytosis. In contrast, serum ferritin levels were high, ranging from 1960 to 4,350 ng/mL. Hep25 levels in three patients were < 5.0 ng/mL. All six patients had hepatocellular iron-positive fibrosis or cirrhosis, five had DM, and three had endocrine disorders. As summarized in Table 4, the clinical features of ILA were characterized by anemia associated with ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis, hyperferritinemia, and hypohepcidinemia. In addition, iron-induced multiorgan damage of chronic liver diseases, cardiac failure, and endocrine diseases, including DM, were reported in ILA.
Three Japanese patients with HFE-CH were newly enrolled in the revised version (Table 2).24,25 A 65-year-old female patient with HC associated with the homozygous mutation of C282Y in HFE was identified in 2001.24 A second family of two patients with HFE-HC associated with homozygous Y231del was identified in 2011.25 A 43-year-old male patient had the typical phenotype of HC with the triad, and responded fairly well to standard phlebotomy. His iron biomarkers measured after treatment were 150 ng/mL for ferritin and 4.0 ng/mL for Hep25. His younger sister with the same genetic background also had DM. However, iron overloading was mild. No significant differences were observed in the clinical features of HFE-HC between Japanese and Caucasian patients (Table 4). Furthermore, there were no new patients with TFR2-HC in the revised version, but TFR2 was one of the major HC gene as well as HJV. HJV-HC was also a major genotype of juvenile HC. Three patients were reported in the first version18 and three were enrolled in the revised version.34,35 As previously reported,18 two siblings of a family received two medical examinations because of the long-term interruption of phlebotomy treatment. The ages of onset of their iron diseases were 13 and 17 years. The ages of onset of HJV-HC in the three new patients were 37, 39, and 52 years (Table 3). Two female patients in a family had DM and hypogonadism34 and a male patient had severe hyperferritinemia of 6,421 ng/mL but iron-induced organ damage was limited to biochemical liver dysfunction.35 A 45-year-old male patient appeared with the HC triad.18 The second examination after phlebotomy treatment at 58 years of age had 16.5 ng/mL for ferritin and BDL for Hep25, and revealed disease-causing mutations in the HAMP gene. As summarized in Table 3, HJV-HC had a wide range of onset ages of between 13 and 52 years. In addition, Japanese patients with HJV- and HAMP-HC had a wide clinical spectrum from juvenile HC to adult-onset traditional HC with cirrhosis, DM, and cardiac failure.
Three patients with SLC40A1-PIOSs were reported in the first version18 and five were newly enrolled in the revised version (Table 2).36–39 Phenotypically, they were divided into five patients with SLC40A1-HC and three with FP-D. Four new patients with SLC40A1-HC were already complicated with multiorgan damage at presentation. All five patients with SLC40A1-HC had high serum ferritin and Hep25 levels and also had advanced chronic liver diseases associated with combined parenchymal and reticuloendothelial iron loading. Four of the five patients were also affected by DM and one had hypopituitarism. In contrast, the three patients with FP-D had selective hyperferritinemia without iron-induced organ damage. An 81-year-old male patient and his 49-year-old son were described in the first study18 and were followed up for more than 10 years.22 The last physical examinations of the father and son were performed at the ages of 90 and 59 years, respectively and found hyperferritinemia, hyperhepcidinemia, and no iron-induced organ damage. A few years later, the father died from malnutrition associated with dysphagia. A 66-year-old woman from another family (Table 3, FP-D-2) who was first enrolled in the revised version remained asymptomatic for 10 years. However, her liver histology showed heavy iron deposits in hepatocytes and Kupffer cells but neither inflammation nor fibrosis. Serum levels of ferritin and Hep25 were high in SLC40A1-PIOSs, and the difference between SLC40A1-HC and FP-D was iron-induced organ damage owing to gain-of-function FP molecules in the former and no organ damage resulting from the loss-of-function FP molecules in the latter (Table 4).
Discussion
The original classification based on the Hep25/FP system included ACP as a prehepatic PIOS.18 In the revised version, the new disease entity of ILA19–21 was included as the second prehepatic PIOS. It is important to note that the number of our patients with ILA was small and their genetic backgrounds were limited. However, iron overload has been found in a number of anemias ranging from traditional thalassemia and CDA to new DHS associated with PIEZO1 mutations.31 ACP11,16,26 and ILA19–21 are now recognized as major prehepatic PIOSs with an impaired Hep/FP system. The terminology of SLC40A1-PIOSs was adjusted in the recent proposal for HC by the BIOIRON Society.23 However, we renamed FP-D in the posthepatic PIOSs. The new FP-D has similar iron loading, but different organ toxicity than SLC40A1-HC. Comparative study of the two phenotypes of SLC40A1-PIOSs is still needed. It is particularly important to clarify why an age-dependent iron accumulation in the liver occurs without change of structure and function in FP-D.18,22
HFE-HC also appeared in the revised version because a Japanese family associated with non-C282Y-HFE-HC was identified in Japan.25 Therefore, the current list of HC was changed from three to four genotypes, which was similar in Caucasians and non-Caucasians. The only difference between the two ethnicities is the markedly higher prevalence of C282Y-HFE-HC in Caucasians.3,4 Regarding the relationship between HC and its genetic background, C282Y per se is a mutation in the HFE gene of HC of PIOSs.1,24 However, accumulated evidence on HC, particularly C282Y-HFE-HC in Caucasians23,28 is important for a more detailed understanding of PIOSs in non-Caucasians. The revised classification of PIOS is now more useful for both Caucasians and non-Caucasians.
In an adult man with an iron overload condition, TFR1 and TFR2 receive iron-saturated TF and release signals that induce the synthesis of a large amount of Hep25 coded by HAMP (Fig. 1). The Hep25/FP system suppresses the iron export function of FP after Hep25-FP complex formation, its internalization, and lysosomal degradation. Enterocytes may then transport a signal to divalent metal transporter1 (DMT1) in order to replace iron stores. As absorbed iron is less than its daily loss, a negative balance is maintained during an iron overload state.13,14
In the prehepatic PIOSs of ACP and ILA, false signals from outside the liver suppress the synthesis of Hep25 (Fig. 2).16,19–21 These false signals are circulating TF with a low TSAT in ACP10 and the increased production of ERFE by erythroblasts in ILA.19–21 Serum levels of Hep25 are low in contrast to hyperferritinemia in patients with ACP11,16 and ILA.19–21 Therefore, the hepatic production of Hep25 and its release into the circulation are suppressed in a prehepatic manner. The four genotypes of HFE, TFR2, HJV, and HAMP-HC are known as hepatic PIOSs.16,18 All HC genotypes have highly saturated TF, but their serum Hep25 levels are reduced to a low level or nearly zero in a hepatic manner13,16,18 as shown in Figure 3A–D. In prehepatic and hepatic PIOSs (Fig. 4), inactivation of the iron exporter FP by Hep25 is negligible; therefore, active FP exports a large amount of iron into the circulation from enterocytes. Iron-vacant enterocytes require DMT1 to absorb a large amount of iron from the diet.13,14 Therefore, the body iron store continues to increase with time.18 In posthepatic PIOSs with SLC40A1 mutants (Fig. 5), the liver releases adequate amounts of Hep25 into the circulation. However, FP, the receptor of Hep25 in enterocytes and macrophages, resists circulating Hep25 without Hep25/FP complex formation, being free from Hep25 control. Gain of function-FP may independently export a large amount of toxic iron and is responsible for SLC40A1-HC, while loss of functionFP may also export a wide range of non-toxic iron in FP-D.17 Therefore, iron absorption does not discontinue in a posthepatic manner.18 Owing to low Hep25 levels in prehepatic and hepatic PIOSs and resistant FP against adequate levels of Hep25 in posthepatic PIOSs, the impaired control of iron export by the Hep25/FP system results in the accumulation of excess iron.18
As summarized in Table 4, the classification may be an excellent base for the diagnosis and treatment of PIOSs in clinical practice.16,18 The first test is an assessment of serum ferritin, which is high in all patients with PIOSs prior to the initiation of treatment. Serum Hep25, a key molecule in PIOSs, needs be measured in all patients. We assessed serum levels of Hep25 in Japanese patients with PIOSs and related iron disorders using LC/ESI-MS/MS.29 It was low in prehepatic and hepatic PIOSs, but became elevated in parallel with ferritin in posthepatic PIOSs.16,18 TSAT is also high in all PIOSs, except for ACP with an inappropriate low TSAT due to a CP (ferroxidase) deficiency.10,16,18 The two prehepatic PIOSs, ACP and ILA, are characterized by deficient CP10,11 and increased ERFE production,19–21 respectively. Hb and CP are all normal in the four genotypes of HC but Hep25 is low or zero in contrast to a high ferritin level.16,18 Posthepatic PIOSs and iatrogenic iron overload, such as repeated transfusions and long-term iron supplementation, are both associated with high serum levels of Hep25 in parallel with serum ferritin levels. A detailed medical history is essential for a differential diagnosis of these two conditions.16,18 We confirmed that FP-D in the three patients was not a premature form of SLC40A1-HC.22 The former may be a selective type of hyperferritinemia,22 while the latter may be complicated by multiorgan damage in the late stage40 similar to hepatic HC.
Various human genetic analyses have been introduced in clinical practice. Serum levels of CP are reduced under many pathological conditions, including Wilson’s disease.16,18 Therefore, direct sequencing of the CP gene may be indicated for a patient with hyperferritinemia associated with hypoceruloplasminemia, for example, a male patient with Wilson’s disease treated by long-term copper chelation.41 ILA is an ERFE-induced PIOS, but not anemia-induced iron overloading.19–21 A wide range of genetic and acquired diseases result in anemias associated with ineffective erythropoiesis and hemolysis. However, the identification of disease-causing mutations in the genes associated with anemias may not be necessary in clinical practice. The direct sequencing of the four HC genes is not an absolute test of genotyping hepatic PIOSs. The C282Y mutation in HFE, which is common in Caucasian HC,3 may be detected by a simple, inexpensive kit.42 When this test is negative, it is necessary to examine all candidate HC genes for mutations,3 as in the case of non-Caucasians.4 It is also important to note that the HJV gene is not only associated with juvenile HC, but also with adult-onset HC.4,18 Mutant-dependent phenotypes have been reported in SLC40A1-PIOSs; therefore, genetic testing for a mutation in the SLC40A1 gene may be clinically useful.16,18 Genetic information on PIOSs may be important in clinical practice, but may not be needed for the clinical diagnosis or management of patients. Even though a patient may have the typical clinical features of a phenotype, a genetic analysis may fail to detect the disease-causing mutation in the postulated gene.40
Patients with HC have excellent tolerance for standard phlebotomy3,4,25 Milder phlebotomy may be recommended for SL40A1-HC3,38 and other phenotypes.3 New oral iron chelators are now available for patients intolerant of phlebotomy. However, the effects of iron chelators on brain iron levels in ACP are controversial.30,43 In ILA, oral iron chelation is the first-line treatment, and transfusion, where needed, needs to be combined with oral chelation. Treatment may not be necessary for FP-D.22
Serum Hep25 is undoubtedly a key molecule in PIOSs, and there are a few laboratories that measure Hep25 in Japan. However, 28% of new patients (5/18) in the revised version did not receive Hep25 testing. A large number of patients with complete clinical data on the Hep25/FP system need to be enrolled for the classification of PIOSs in the future.
Conclusions
The genetic background of PIOS differs in Caucasians and non-Caucasians.2 Therefore, physicians have to overcome differences in the global prevalence of PIOS in clinical practice. The Hep25/FP system classifies PIOSs as prehepatic ACP and ILA, hepatic HC, and posthepatic SLC40A1-HC and FP-D. The revised classification for PIOSs may be useful worldwide.
Abbreviations
- ACP:
aceruloplasminemia
- BDL:
below the detection limit
- BMP:
bone morphogenetic protein
- BMPR:
bone morphogenetic protein receptor
- CDA:
congenital dyserythropoietic anemia
- CNS:
central nervous system
- CP:
ceruloplasmin
- DM:
diabetes mellitus
- DHS:
dihydrated hereditary stomatocytosis
- DMT1:
divalent metal transporter1
- ERFE:
erythroferrone
- F:
female
- FP:
ferroportin
- FP-D:
ferroportin disease
- HAMP:
human antimicrobial peptide
- Hb:
hemoglobin
- HC:
hemochromatosis
- Hep25:
hepcidin25
- HFE:
hemochromatosis protein
- HJV:
hemojuvelin
- ILA:
iron-loading anemia
- M:
male
- nd:
not determined
- Ph:
phlebotomy
- PIOS:
primary iron overload syndrome
- Ref:
reference
- TF:
transferrin
- SLC40A1:
gene name of ferroportin1
- TFR:
transferrin receptor
- TSAT:
transferrin saturation
Declarations
Acknowledgement
The authors wish to acknowledge Dr. Naohisa Tomosugi, Kanazawa Medical College, for measuring serum Hep25 levels.
Ethical statement
The protocol of the present study was prepared in accord with the Declaration of Helsinki and Ethical Guidelines for Medical and Biological Research Involving Human Subjects issued by the Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry of Japan (revised in 2023.3.27). Informed consent was obtained from each patient before the assessment of serum Hep25 levels and a genetic analysis of iron overload syndromes. Instead of informed consent, OPTOUT was permitted for patients. The draft of the present study was prepared in accordance with the STROBE statement. Finally, the statement of the classification of PIOSs in an international journal was approved by the Ethics Committees of the Aichi-Gakuin University School of Pharmacy and other institutes. The new classification of PIOSs is not duplicated, but revised from the original classification published in 2012. The new disease entity ILA is registered in the revised version and the terminology is renewed according to the proposal for HC by the BIOIRON Society. This manuscript is not under consideration for publication by any other journal.
Data sharing statement
No additional data are available.
Funding
None to declare.
Conflict of interest
KH has been an Editorial Board Member of Journal of Clinical and Translational Hepatology since 2013. The other authors have no conflict of interests related to this publication.
Authors’ contributions
Conceptualization (YT, MY, HM, SI, KK, HH, KH), methodology (YT, SW, TN, WN, AK), investigation (YT, WN, AK), writing original draft (MY, TI, SI, AT, WN, AK), writing review, and editing (YT, SW, KK, HH, KY, KH), and supervision (YT, MY, SW, HM, KK, HH, KY, KH).